Service Mode

The Pub That Knew What It Was

A proper local offered more ways to enjoy it than the first impression suggested, without losing its character.

A pint of beer on the bar in an independent pub

Halfway through a long walk, I stopped for a pint.

The pub looked like a proper local, which was exactly what I wanted. Nothing about it suggested that it was trying to be all things to all people.

Then I started noticing things.

On the bar was a cabinet of pies and sausage rolls, with the prices clearly displayed. Beside the pumps, a small chalkboard listed non-alcoholic drinks.

A sign behind the bar offered herbal teas and instant coffee.

Above the fire was an impressive scrumpy board. A shelf over a nook held jars of retro sweets. Even the sign on the door explained the rules around dogs and children.

It was quite a collection.

You could come in for a pint of cider, a cup of tea, something alcohol-free, a sausage roll or some sweets. You could arrive with a dog or children and know where you stood.

And somehow none of this made the pub feel as though it was trying particularly hard to accommodate everyone.

It just did.

A broad offer doesn’t need to change the place

There’s an easy way to broaden a hospitality business.

Add things.

More food. More drinks. A coffee menu. Cocktails. Children’s meals. Brunch. Perhaps an açai bowl if nobody intervenes in time.

Eventually, the business may appeal to more people. It may also become difficult to work out what sort of place it is.

This pub had taken a different approach.

It hadn’t transformed itself to accommodate different customers. It had simply thought about what those customers might reasonably want while they were there.

The coffee is a good example.

There was no espresso machine dominating the bar. No elaborate coffee menu. No suggestion that the pub had developed strong opinions about the correct weight of a flat white.

It offered instant coffee.

In some places that might feel inadequate. Here it made perfect sense.

If somebody wanted a coffee while everyone else had a pint, they could have one.

Problem solved.

The alternatives fitted the pub

That distinction matters.

Adding something to the offer is easy. Adding something that belongs there takes a little more judgement.

The pies and sausage rolls fitted. So did the scrumpy. So did the jars of sweets.

But so, strangely enough, did the herbal tea.

None of these things was trying to pull the pub in a different direction. They simply gave more people a way to use the place that already existed.

The alcohol-free options are perhaps the clearest example.

A group of four doesn’t necessarily choose a pub because all four people want beer. One may be driving. Someone may not drink. Someone else may simply not fancy alcohol that afternoon.

If the alternatives are poor or invisible, the group has to make a choice. They can ask what else is available, leave one person with a drink they don’t really want or go somewhere that works for all four. A small gap in the offer can influence where the whole group ends up.

Here, they already had options.

The pub hadn’t changed what it was for them.

It had just made sure there was something for them when they arrived.

Small things can widen the invitation

The retro sweets initially seemed like a completely separate detail.

Then they made more sense.

They’re cheap, simple and entirely at home in an old-fashioned pub. But if you’re there with a child, that jar suddenly becomes considerably more interesting.

The same was true of the information about dogs and children. It didn’t need a grand statement about being family-friendly or dog-friendly. It simply made clear how both fitted into the place.

That was the pattern.

Not a huge range designed to capture every conceivable customer.

Just lots of small decisions that made it easier for different people to enjoy the same pub together.

Having it isn’t enough

There was another reason all of this worked.

You could see it.

The pies and sausage rolls were on the bar with their prices. The alcohol-free drinks had their own chalkboard. Tea and coffee were signposted. The scrumpy certainly wasn’t hiding. Even the rules around dogs and children were explained before you came in.

That matters more when something isn’t an obvious part of the offer.

Walk into a pub and you’ll probably ask what beer it has. You’re less likely to ask whether it happens to have herbal tea, alcohol-free drinks or something small to eat if there’s no other indication that it does.

Which creates an odd problem. A business can broaden its offer to include more people, then leave those people unaware that it has done so.

The pub avoided that without covering the room in promotional material. The signs were small, informal and appropriate to the place. They didn’t feel like marketing.

They just answered questions before anyone needed to ask them.

And that may be the useful test for any less obvious part of an offer: if the customer has to know it exists before they’ll think to ask for it, how are they supposed to discover it?

This is different from trying to please everyone

There’s a danger in taking this idea too far.

A pub that tries to satisfy every possible customer can end up satisfying none of them particularly well.

The answer isn’t necessarily a longer menu, another fridge or seventeen varieties of tea.

It starts with understanding the occasions the business already serves.

Who comes in with the people you consider your core customers?

What might stop the whole group choosing you?

And is there a small, credible way of removing that objection without changing what makes the place distinctive?

Sometimes the answer might be a serious alcohol-free beer range. Somewhere else it might be a couple of simple food options outside normal kitchen hours, decent soft drinks or, apparently, a jar of cola cubes.

The important bit is that the solution belongs in the room.

Confidence makes this easier

What I liked most about the pub was that none of this seemed apologetic.

The instant coffee wasn’t pretending to be café coffee. The food wasn’t pretending to be a restaurant menu. The sweets weren’t pretending to be anything at all.

The pub didn’t seem worried that offering these things would somehow dilute its identity.

Perhaps that’s because its identity was already so obvious.

And that feels like the useful lesson.

Independent hospitality businesses often spend a lot of time thinking about their target customer. Sensibly so. Trying to appeal to everybody is usually a good way of becoming generic.

But there’s a difference between knowing who you are and unnecessarily excluding everyone else.

A strong identity can actually make a broader offer easier, because every addition doesn’t have to become a new direction for the business. It can simply solve a small problem for somebody who is already there, or would like to be.

None of this made the pub feel less like a proper local.

If anything, the confidence worked the other way. It knew exactly what sort of place it was, so offering a herbal tea, a sausage roll or a bag of sweets wasn’t going to cause an identity crisis.

Being clear about what you are doesn’t require being narrow about who you’re for.

Continue reading

The Menu With No Hours